Most pitches aren't pitches.
They're a founder's bio wearing a trench coat, trying to sneak into a journalist's inbox.
And then the founder tells me, "PR doesn't work. I emailed 40 reporters and nobody wrote back."
Brother, PR didn't fail. The email did.
So let's do a teardown. I wrote the pitch below myself, so nobody gets embarrassed. But if you've ever sent a pitch, or received one, you've seen this exact email a hundred times.
Subject: Exciting news from Acme!
Hi there,
My name is Dave and I'm the founder and CEO of Acme, an innovative, AI-powered platform revolutionizing the way small businesses manage their finances.
We just launched version 2.0, which includes a brand new dashboard, real-time reporting, and integrations with all major accounting tools.
We've been growing fast and have an amazing team. I'd love to be featured in your publication. Let me know if you're interested!
Best,
Dave
Looks harmless. Polite. Professional, even.
It's dead on arrival. Let's go line by line.
Exciting to who?
The subject line is the whole pitch for most reporters. It's the only part a lot of them will ever read. And this one says nothing except "a company you've never heard of is excited."
Nobody opens an email because a stranger is excited. They open it because the subject line hints at a story they could write.
A subject line should sound like a headline the reporter would be proud to run. Not a press release from your own marketing department.
You didn't look up their name.
That tells them you didn't read their work either. And if you didn't read their work, you have no idea if this story fits their beat. Which means this is a mass email. Which means it gets treated like one.
Thirty seconds of research beats three hours of writing.
Here's where the pitch actually dies.
Innovative. AI-powered. Revolutionizing. Three words every company on earth uses about itself. They don't describe anything. They're filler that makes you sound exactly like the last ten emails.
And notice who the sentence is about. Dave. Dave's company. Dave's platform.
A journalist's job isn't to make you famous. Their job is to give their readers a story worth reading. If your pitch is about you, you've just asked them to do free marketing for you. Hard pass.
This is a feature list.
Features are for your sales page. Stories are for the press.
No reader has ever shared an article titled "Company Adds Dashboard." But they'll read about the bakery owner who almost lost her shop because she couldn't see her cash flow until it was too late.
That's the same product. One version is a feature. The other is a person with a problem, and stakes, and an ending.
The client is the hero. The customer is the hero. Your product is the sidekick at best. Most founders write themselves as the hero and then wonder why nobody wants to watch the movie.
Says who?
"Growing fast" with no number is a vibe, not a fact. "Amazing team" is something your mom would say. A reporter can't print either one.
If you have a real number you can stand behind, use it. If you don't, don't fake one. Cut the line and lean on the story instead. Empty claims make the rest of the email look empty too.
This is the line that tells the reporter exactly what's going on.
You want something from them. You haven't offered anything back.
There's no angle. No reason this matters right now. No data, no trend, no customer, no opinion they could quote. Just "please feature me."
That's begging for attention. And attention you beg for is the most expensive kind. You pay for it with your credibility.
Strip it down and this pitch has no answer to the only three questions a reporter cares about:
If your pitch can't answer those in a few sentences, it's not ready to send. It's ready to rewrite.
Same made-up founder. Same made-up company. Different approach:
Subject: The cash flow mistake that's quietly killing small shops
Hi Sarah,
Your piece last month on small retailers closing after the holidays stuck with me.
We see the other side of that story every day. Most of the owners who come to us aren't losing money. They're losing visibility. They find out they're short when the rent bounces, not weeks before when they could've fixed it.
I'm happy to walk you through what that looks like and the three warning signs owners can check this week. I can also connect you with a customer who's willing to talk about almost closing.
Worth a chat?
Dave, founder of Acme
Look at what changed.
The subject line is a headline. The opener proves he read her work. The story is about shop owners, not Acme. There's a "why now." There's something useful for her readers. There's a real person she can interview.
And the product? Barely mentioned. Because if the story lands, the reporter will ask what you do. That's the point. Let them ask.
Even the rewrite isn't magic.
A great pitch gets you a glance. Then the reporter googles you. If page one is empty or messy, the glance ends there. I wrote about that a couple of weeks ago, and it's still the step most founders skip.
So the job is two things. Write pitches about stories, not about you. And make sure that when someone checks you out, there's proof waiting for them.
Do that, and PR stops feeling like shouting into a void. It starts feeling like a conversation people actually want to have.
Stop pitching your product. Start pitching the story your product is the sidekick in.
Send me the pitch you're about to send, or the one that got ignored. I'll go through it the same way, line by line, and tell you what I'd cut, what I'd keep, and what story you're sitting on without realizing it.
Book a free PR audit here: https://calendly.com/dontbealittlepitch/30-min-meeting
Worst case, you send a better email. Best case, someone finally writes back.